21+  Information & entertainment only — we never take bets. Gamble responsibly: 1-800-GAMBLER
Longshot Edge
Home/MLB/New York Mets @ New York Yankees
MLB · 2026-09-12

New York Mets vs New York Yankees

Yankee Stadium

New York Mets
68-79
VS
New York Yankees
85-62
53%
New York Yankees win probability · -157
Tale of the tape
47%Win probability53%
0.463Win %0.578
-42Run differential+133
Toss-up-157 · BetOnline.ag
New York Yankees to win
The market (61%) rates this higher than our model (53%) — no real edge, so we pass.

Our read leans New York Yankees over New York Mets — a 53% win probability once everything is weighed. Essentially a coin flip at 53% — entertainment only, not a spot to press. Pitching matchup: Gerrit Cole (3.41 ERA) vs Zac Thornton (3.53 ERA).

Why we lean this way

  • Form & record: New York Yankees sit 85-62 (0.578), New York Mets 68-79 (0.463).
  • Last 10: New York Yankees 7-3 (W4), New York Mets 7-3 (L1). Hot streaks move these lines fast.
  • Run differential: New York Yankees +133, New York Mets -42 on the year — the most honest measure of how good a team actually is, beyond their record.
  • On the mound: New York Yankees hand the ball to Gerrit Cole; New York Mets counter with Zac Thornton. Starting pitching swings a baseball game more than any other factor.
  • Home field: worth about +3.5% to New York Yankees in our model.

The verdict

Bottom line: New York Yankees to win is a near coin-flip. Treat it like a 53% spot — not a sure thing, because there is no such thing. Size it sensibly and enjoy the game.

Logged to our public track record and graded after the final. We analyze; we never take wagers. 21+.

Get the daily edge in your inbox

Every morning: the day's best bets, the smart fun parlay, and what's worth watching — free, no spam.

21+. Informational and entertainment content only.